In the number of booklets that my Daddy published, where he had constructive suggestions to make India the most powerful Nation in the world, one of them dealt with the Farms and Arms theory. He felt that to break the vicious circle of over population, ignorance, ill distribution of land, uneconomic holdings, and failure of the government to introduce land reforms, we should produce enough food in State farms run by the Army personnel.
His conception…and I quote ‘was of a productive army that would be self- reliant and which would make the country self sufficient in food. The first charge of such an army would be to kill our real enemy- hunger. In other words let our army have the satisfaction of protecting a nation of healthy people, not semi-starved skeletons.’
Perhaps some of Daddy’s suggestions were weird but a few of his ideas, like raising the marriageable age of the girls, were actually incorporated by the government. He also proudly insisted that Shashtriji’s slogan ‘Jai Jawan Jai Kisan’ had actually been coined after Daddy had sent him the booklet ‘Farms for Arms’.
Even if I don’t agree with some of Daddy’s theories, I still have a lot of respect for the two unsung professions of our country- that of the Kisan and of the Jawan. Both do not exactly have jobs where they can come forward in their best suits, embellish their resumes, undergo a series of interviews, find a job in the office and then relax and carry on giving their autographs on endless files. In fact it is just the opposite.
The Kisan is forever being promised that globalisation will ultimately bring new techniques and knowledge in his once- upon- a- time outdated ‘field’. And he lives on hope. But we all know that agricultural fecundity is not godsend. This direct product of human toil is what we Indians call paseene ki kamaai. And in spite of all the green revolution, the Indian farmer still continues to remain in a state of extreme physical and mental distress.
The Jawan is forever being given an assurance that one day, when war is ruled out and peace reigns, history will finally take note of his heroic deeds. But everyone knows that there is human suffering more at the hands of each other than through natural disasters. And whenever the clarion call of Peace is played, the world chooses to be deaf. Bertrand Russel felt that war does not determine who is right- only who is left. I can imagine the final act before Operation Earth is carried out- A sole survivor standing atop a barren globe and proudly declaring- ‘Ha! Russel was right after all. I am the only one left!’
For the Jawan and the Kisan, a fragment of agony is always present in their thankless jobs. And I feel that both these kind of heroes are nothing but digits on a balance sheet. More like lifeless objects that can be used and then discarded. For all said and done it is the bigwigs that often take credit and none of these actual heroes are even present on the stage whenever the curtain falls!
Rather, in our nation of 62 long independent years, heroes are those that garner runs on a field, revive the tradition of Swayamvars, make their private moments of truth public, keep alive their lineage by the name game, or through the misuse of state exchequer make their permanence felt by etching themselves in stone. And at the altar of dignity, it is only the Jawan and the Kisan that are sacrificed again and again.
The Kisan toils so that we can eat. The soldier dies so that we can live. And what does a nation that has always been infected with the Spine Flu give them in return? Bury their JaiJaikaars and sing Jai Ho instead. Or make stupid policies like awarding compensation for committing suicides. Or give them the royal ignore as far as the pay commission is concerned.
The least we can do is immortalise them and not our ‘living’ leaders. When the entire world looks up to their heroes for their valour and their drudgery, why can’t we give some form of visibility to our invisible heroes? For every farmer buried in debt and for every soldier done to death, it’s about time we constructed a memorial- perhaps a mammoth sculpture of a man with arms and a man with a plough. And what better words to engrave upon the monument than ‘Jai Jawan! Jai Kisan!’
Poste below are a few of the memorials I saw on our trip to the US of A.
<
There is a beautiful Immigration Museum in the Ellis Island. It chronicles the immigrant heritage and honours even those that arrived unannounced and settled there. This is just 'one of the many in memory of the immigrants'. It was taken while we were lining up to go see the statue of Liberty.
The Iwo Jima Memorial- dedicated to the marines who gave their lives during one of the most historic battles of World War II. You can ignore the two figures sitting below. They have nothing to do with valour ;-}
The 'field of the dead where Valour proudly sleeps.'It is called the National Arlington Cemetry.
A walk in this solemn park is like an excercise for your soul.
I heard a very interesting conversation here. An old lady was explaining to a boy about how soldiers, with their families were laid here and continue to be buried even now. 'And what happens when we run out of place Grandma?' the child asked. I didn't wait to hear what the lady said. For most this would seem like an innocuous question. For me it was the wisest definition of the futility of war!
The tomb of the Unknown Soldier. This is guarded throughout the day. This is the change of guard, which takes place every hour.
The World War II Memorial. The whole plaza is dead with a revered kind of silence. And yet it is alive with rememberance. Only because the crowds that throng here daily ensure that every day is Memorial Day!
Unlike us the Americans are smart. They not only look up to their heroes but also ensure that everyone else who goes there, looks up to them as well!
10 comments:
It’s strange how some images which linger for more than four decades get refreshed in a jiffy.
The image I am talking about is me being left to the ‘mercy’ of the compounder while my dad had plenty of time to chat with Doctor saheb. Now I have come to know that Doctor Saheb was also a writer and a thinker and I am sure they used to discuss things like India after Nehru, India under Indira, the perils of mixed economy…..This is a facet of Doctor Saheb that I was totally unaware of.
Your take on the schizophrenic Indian society is spot on. What else can one say other than, “We are Indians. We are like that only.”
Time to move on....... Mohatarma Rakhi Sawant ji is now adopting children live on TV!!!
Very well written prose. Your dad was a respected teacher of my father and now I realise where the communist (I am sure people on this blog would prefer the word "socialist") frame of mind was acquired from.....he is now the choda hua khota sikka of communism !!!(just kidding).
My histroy and knowleddge about sculptures is very weak.....but monuments like India Gate, etc. were built for similar purpose ? And regarding a statue with the farmer and soldier, I do remember one in Delhi.....maybe somewhere on the way from Connaught Place to the airport.
And Arun, please tell me you are joking about Rakhi Sawant !!!
Dear kausty,
Long time no hear. Good to see you in the blog hope all is well at your end. I wish the rakhi kay bachhe show was a joke but no, it isn’t. It will be aired next month, the promos are on. Jokes are those that the Government and the society at large play on the jawans and the kisans.
Though Nargis is better qualified to talk about India Gate, I cannot resist to add some facts on the so called great Indian war memorial:
- It was built by the British. Lutyens to be precise
- It was built in 1930’s to commemorate the death of Indian soldiers who specifically died on Her Majesty’s Service during the World War- I and the Anglo- Afghan Wars.
- The names of those soldiers are actually inscribed on the walls
- After 1947 the smart Alecs in Indian Government removed the statue of King George from beneath the gate and began giving the impression that it is a war memorial for Indian soldiers.
- In 1971 Indira Gandhi pulled another fast one by lighting the Amar Jyoti there and began commemorating the valiant soldiers who died during the Bangladesh liberation War.
- In short we have not yet built a proper war memorial for Indian soldiers who died and are dying protecting our borders.
- And that is why six months or so down the line the big attraction on the TV screens will probably be Rakhi ka divorce live. Farmer’s suicides and truant monsoons will soon be forgotten.
- Jawans and Kisans are two faces of the same coin.
- I have a very strong feeling that 90% of the jawans who die for their motherland are actually sons of poor kisans who could not afford their sons education so send them to join the army. Similarly the number of soldiers or officers dying for India and being the sons of MP’s and MLA’s would be 0%
- I may sound cynical but what to do? We Indians are like that only….
Thanks Arun,
That was a good lesson for me in history !! And yes, I will have to agree with the likelyhood of Jawans being the sons of Kisans. The senior officers in the defence are from better (?!?!) background.
I am just wondering how the channel which will telecast the Rakhi Sawant thing is able to get around the adoption laws of the country ? One thing is that the adopting family is not allowed (legally) to see the child.....they can only be sent the profile. The socond thing is what happens to the emotions of all the children who will be rejected ?
Me and my wife have been thinking about adopting a girl for some time now, but the sheer amount of legal formalities has slowed us down......but the process being made into a public farce will certainly hurt a lot of people !!
Thsnk God, there is still programs line India's Got Talent......hopefully everyone here keeps voting for Prince Dance Group !!
Mummy has preserved some of Daddy's correspondence with Dr Radhakrishnan - Mr Vinobha Bhave - Shastri Ji and the like. Jai Ho!
On Adoption...
Ofcourse Raakhi Sawant likes to adopt foreign bodies!
A point about Indians - based on casual observation by my sons, on the last trip, goes s'thing like "... Indians accept everything, bad roads, stray animals, crowded vehicles ...". I guess what they meant (I am extrapolating here) is that we Indians do not set standards (good ones) for ourselves.
Case in point - we as a group of people, will never get together and demand local authorities to do something serious about say overcrowded roads n such.
Added to that we suffer from "wishful thinking" (e.g. wish India wins the World Cup in Hockey) w/o. an iota of any kinda effort.
Spewing out good verbiage, is just that!
Nargis you are absolutely right- we do need more war memorials built specifically for our war heroes. There are some memorials in the barracks( wasnt there one at Bams 'barkas'?) but we need them at public places
Okay guys....My dotter and son-in-law from Aphreeka are here. This is the first time they are visiting after her wedding...hence busy. Right now they have gone to see what else but the world famous in orissa our very own Nandankanan Joo...:-} So I thought I should reply to the comments....
Arun: As far as I can remember we had an interesting character in our compounder Fazal....in fact sometimes he thought he was a shade more qualified than even the daktar saab...:-} As for Rakhi, I don't think it is a case of adoption, it is more of a game show that she and her fiance will be performing....playing mommy and daddy for a month or so...ABS CRAZY!!!!
Kausty: Actually Arun has given a better analysis of India Gate. Now 'm really angry. I really thought at least that was one memorial we had that was exclusively built by 'us'. Ironically even the Anthem that we sing is actually in praise of King George. Daddy had some qualms about that too and that was one more controversy he had got into....I have chronicled all those facts in my book...:-}
Faiyaz: Yes, I had got hold of a few of his correspondence with some leaders while writing the book but now mummy has hidden it in such a secure place that even she cannot find them...:-{
Hilu: Must say your kids are very observant. Indians do tend to have a high degree of acceptance with an air of nonchalance that qualifies for their famous 'chalta hai' kind of attitude...and it is not as if we 'only' are like that...it is more like we are like that only....:-}
NRK: The 'barkas' grounds has a memorial? Next time I go I must pay my respects...:-} And maybe add it in my 'memorial' blog and make Bhrampapur a little more phamous...:-}
I found it funny to know that even at Hyderabad, the Barracks area is referred to as 'Barkas'.
BTW, good points, Nargis and Arun.
Good post, Nargis... Keep writing.
The comments section too are now becoming like posts with great content...
Noble thoughts Kausty... I could put you on to someone (from SVC)who went thro the entire process - if it could be of some help...
Post a Comment