Wednesday, 1 April 2009

Masak-kali, Masak-kali and the plight of the pigeons



It’s beyond doubt. Age and awareness are accomplices to murder- the murder of innocence and that too the pure and pristine innocence nurtured from childhood.

The other day a flock of pigeons brought home this brutal point.

Not so much in Berhampur but it was in Cuttack that I noticed that many in my neighbourhood had pigeons on their rooftops. Once released from their pigeonholes they would soar towards the skies. Everyday early in the morning they would flap their wings ungainly and circle around the house. After a few minutes of freedom, the owner would call them with a slightly over-exaggerated throaty beckon call, “Aaaaaaaa, Aaaaa, Aaaa, Aa.” They would then descend happily and eat the grains spread for them. The loud flapping of their wings and their equally sonorous, “guttaar guttaar” was real music to ears. Nice neighbourhood, Nice souls, I thought about such people. A feeling that I carried with me for over three decades.

A few years back I began a closer relationship with these lovely pigeons. My elder brother began feeding them on his rooftop. Soon the trickle became a torrent and believe it or not almost a hundred pigeons descend every morning for their feast. This became one of the ‘highs’ during my trips to Bubaneshwar.

It became a daily morning ritual. We would throw the grains and pigeons would come flapping wildly to our rooftop. You could then sit in a reclining chair, sip your morning cuppa tea, browse through the newspapers or simply gossip about this and that with your family members while the birds would be busy feasting. The more adventurous would literally eat out of your hands. And all the while they would make that guttar guttar noise.

I could identify three personality types. The fat ones (motoos) would monopolize areas of the roof where others dare not enter. The smart ones (chaaloos) would go to those areas not frequented by the fat ones yet grab a good meal. The meek ones (darpoks) would wait for their turn in safe corners. I noticed that there were also the romantic ones who would even steal a kiss or two in between their breakfast!! Who says there is time and place for everything? Tell it to the birds!!

The endearing nature of this feathered species was also reinforced by the fact that they were considered reliable and faithful carriers of love letters penned by romantics during the age when love was a crime. In fact history is a witness to the fact that emperors and generals used pigeons regularly for carrying their messages across hostile terrain. The Orissa police still have these feathered faithful in their ranks. When Nehru inaugurated the Hirakud dam he had to address a meeting in Cuttack the next day. The report of the dam inauguration was carried by a pigeon in four hours flat and was available in Cuttack even before Nehru had arrived!!

Then came the film Delhi 6 and the Masak Kali song. It’s a hummabale light fun tune which along with its slick promos pushed me into seeing the film. But the film itself brought home a different grim reality. Masak kali, the most beautiful pigeon, could not fly. Why was it so? The answer was simple- because she was the most beautiful and therefore the owners favourite. And the owner, fearing the risk of losing her, clipped her wings. A heavy price indeed that Masak kali had to pay for being beautiful.

Things quickly fell in place for me. The unusual extra effort that the pigeons were making to fly when I had encountered them in childhood was probably because of this. The owners of these pigeons were not good Samaritans after all. They had clipped the wings of their ‘loved’ ones ensuring that they couldn’t fly far.

I felt sad but little did I realize that worse was still to come.

Last week, in a distant village, I noticed a series of earthen pots hanging at the roof-top level of a thatched hut. “What’s that?”, I enquired. I was told that pigeons invariably lay their eggs in a very safe corner and an earthen pot tilted at a particular angle was their most favoured egg laying site. The pigeons too consider it their home and spend the nights there in the relative warmth of the earthen pots.

“Oh, a good Samaritan who loves birds,” I said aloud. “Good Samaritan my foot”, retorted my colleague. “He is doing this because he supplements his income by selling pigeon meat”. After enticing them with love for years he was simply waiting for them to fatten so that he could get a good price. Once the bargain was struck, all that the owner now had to do was to put the lid on the earthen pot.

It was like being struck by lightning. Call it ignorance, innocence or sheer idiocy I had never ever thought that these innocent lovable birds were actually being ‘loved’ and reared for their meat. That the cute carriers of love letters were actually a source of culinary delight simply devastated me.

It sure was a recipe for a perfect murder - the murder of innocence.

Fly pigeon fly

When shall you learn about your folly?
When shall you read the tell tale signs?
When shall you realize,
That the hand that feeds you,
Shall one day feast on you?

Fly pigeon fly,
You know not what’s in store for you.

When you eat out of his palms,
When your perch on his shoulders,
When you straddle on his rooftop,
When you walk down the courtyard,
Don’t you see those feathers
That once belonged to your brothers?
Don’t you see that blood stain
Where your parents died in pain?
Don’t you ever look around
And miss your friends that no longer surround?

Fly pigeon fly,
You know not what’s in store for you.

Never have I tied a letter around you,
With heartfelt lines for the lovely lady.
Never have I ordered armies to advance,
With a message tied to your slender legs.
The lover,
The emperor,
The general,
Always have used you,
The message I have is just for you:
For you are:
My love,
My innocence,
My fractured soul.

And the message is worth repeating till my last breath:

Fly pigeon fly,
You know not what’s in store for you.

P.S:
With due apologies to all those who relish pigeon meat.

Posted by Picasa

26 comments:

Omkar said...

2 comments -

a) Such is life

b) Love never is/was a crime. Who one falls in love with, whoa, that's a different story!!!

Seetha said...

What a fantastic piece Arun. I have eaten all kinds of meat over the years, but after reading this, pigeon meat is one I will not eat!!

arun bhatt said...

hi omkar,

love is not a crime but to pretend that you are in love and then after years of such false love you slash it for food that is the kind of hypocricy that this write-up hopes to expose.but then you are right 'such is life'.

hi seetha,

thanks for the compliment. don't take my emotional write-ups too seriously you will end being a vegeterian who believes in meditation and yoga!!!!

Naresh said...

One more marathon ! The congregation reminds me of the 'Gateway of India ' Pigeons '.

The flip side is you are left with too much of litter where pigeons dwell.

And they breed fast too !

Kausty said...

Pegion meat, I never had. They are pretty creatures, but like Naresh said, I am not too keen on the litter they make.
The pegions end up in the cooking pot because of love and a lot of human end up in the kitchen !
But I guess it is trust which is more at stake here. Being trusted is a virtue, trusting is a folly.....just made it up !!
But great write-up Arun.

Kausty said...

By the way Arun, I am not good at writing, etc and so never tried to do anything about the "Samaj" and Dr. Radhanath Rath issue. However, if you are interested and have time next time in CTC, I can request my father to talk about his experiences with Dr. Rath and also be able to take you through the Samaj building and be your guide....got to ask him first though.

arun bhatt said...

Naresh,

They sure breed fast otherwise we humans could have wiped out this species. And I am glad they litter otherwise many more would be tempted to 'nurture' and 'love' them.

Kausty,

"Being trusted is a virtue, trusting is a folly." Absolutely great line.... top drawer philosophy.

Since you don't write I will use this as my orignial somewhere sometime!!!! just joking.

Thanks for the Samaj offer. It will be great talking to your dad and going around the building when i got to ctk. next.

Enarkay said...

Great piece Arun. Arent chickens also raised in a similar way? Being fattened for the kill?
Your poetry is very good. Now we have a photo-poem

Vimal Parmar said...

True Hindi movie style... good beginning but a sad ending. In any case, a GREAT write-up!
In our factory in Berhampur we had hundreds of pigeons. First it was the slots under the roof and then they started occupying pockets in the residential area roof top. The fun was watching them take off together... They would circle the entire area and then land in groups... what a sight!
The pigeon post in Orissa is probably the last surviving one in the world. I read sometime back that there are around 1000+ pigeons spread across several pigeon posts in Orissa and would be grounded anytime...

arun bhatt said...

Enarkay,

you are right there are many animals and birds that are reared for meat. but do we profess the same love to say chickens, fishes, goats etc.? Simply 'closing the lid' one fine day after years of rearing just jolted me. my biggest shock was that somehow very stupidly i never realised that they are eaten. however let me put the record straight i am not championing vegetarianism. to each his own.

Vims,

you are right even i read about that a few years ago. the problem was not so much the pigeons but the 800 odd personnel required to train them. in the era of internet, fax, telephone, mobile etc. this was a luxury that orissa police could ill afford.

Tasneem said...

Ah! Pigeons…they remind me so much of the good old days when we were posted in Delhi.
We were staying in this railway apartment on the 7th floor at Panchkuin Rd. Every morning and evening our balcony was the “adda “ of flocks of pigeons. What a mess they made of my sit-out and as for my plants, they were forever at their mercy. There was no end to my maid’s grumbling about the extra cleaning up that she had to do. My husband, Jason however, firmly believed that a house which is frequented by doves is a blessed house. He bought special grain and water troughs for his dear pigeons and every night, before going to bed, would personally replenish them. He would make sure that their “dana” was included in our monthly grocery list and if it was forgotten, he would personally go and buy it from the nearby “kirana” shop at Paharganj!
I must admit it was very calming to be in their midst while sipping our morning tea in the balcony, before the hustle & bustle of the day started. Our kids too had come to love them and my son (he was 2 then) would gurgle with joy whenever they came close to him.
Like you, AB, my daughter had names for her favourites-I remember one plump thing was called “Chubby”, another one was “Kiran” ! Wonder how she could identify them. Some of them probably belonged to someone as they had metal rings around their feet. .. but we preferred to believe they were more fond of us than their owners as they always made a beeline for our balcony!
Our transfer to Bangalore brought an end to our tryst with our gentle feathered friends (aren't they called Para in Oriya?) and we missed them so much.

Nargis said...

Hey Arun....

What a fantastic write up! I simply love that number 'Masak Kali'only for the reason that I have quite a few of them matakallis visiting our house here almost everyday. I put a little of the daana that attracts also the sparrrows. Like Tas says, even I beleive a houseful of pigeons is a blessed home. So one should never try to shoo them off...the litter doesn't matter. The only interesting thing is when Nelson (my cat)sits watching them go guttar guttar from a distance with a lot of hope in his eyes....maybe I should make HIM read this moving piece of yours :-}But luckily he doesn't do anything....perhaps cos he's the only cat amongst the pigeons...hahaha....

Goodness, I never knew even pigeons were meat. I thought people loved them all over the world- trafalgar square, gateway of india, marine drive, dubai(forget the name)you find them everywhere...or is it only for the photo sessions which they can carry back home? Anywayz, never touched pigeon meat. And after reading this never will.
Lovely poem....:-}

Tasneem said...

Pigeon meat is considered an aphrodisiac, but go easy on it...its high purine content is lethal for gout sufferers!

Naresh said...

Tas

For that matter.. Rhino's horn is a time tested Aphrodisiac ( Viagara, bye , bye ).

Your Panchkuian and Paharganj narration takes me back to memory lane. Spent 12 years in DELHI. Har 'gulley' or nukkad se waqif thay ! Obviously Marketing guys have nothing more to do !

arun bhatt said...

Tas,
glad to know your entire family love pigeons. they really are an endearing species.

I have also come across numerous "rationalizations" for loving the meat. Aphrodisiac and giving your warmth in the winter are the easiest reasons.

can you beat it the tribal in jharkhand actually told me that pigeon blood if applied on the head actually cures baldness.may be he was trying to rope me in considering that i am now going bald very quick!!

Nargis,
yes we all love a good photo opportunity but then on the dining table i guess a different set of values come in.
the best con job on pigeons is probably in bangkok. there in a temple you can (for a price of course) free a caged bird that actually happens to be a trained pigepon. you feel good about having done noble deed but little do you realise that the pigeon flies to the 'owners' house in the adjacent locality only to be recycled again!! As long as he does this trick at least he wont be eaten.

Faiyaz said...

I love both MK and SK!
(Masak Kali and Sonam Kapoor)

Great Post Anil!

arun bhatt said...

"Great post Anil" reminds me how i once said hi nigar to nargis!!!

Nargis said...

And not to forget how Venu thought YOU had not only posted the blog but ALSO written the book.

And of how Vinita thought Tas had written the book.

Poor mua...all that hard work and no recognition...:-{ Btw...'Anil'Ji have you read the book or not? Or not upto your mark...hahaha!

arun bhatt said...

Nargis ji,

to be honest i have read about 100 odd pages when the 'danger boy', the malaysian neighbour('sollright') and the couple with the baggage of the past are driving out of KL. the husband cracks a few sardarji jokes and the lady snaps..... thats when I lost the book!!

Now either the book is in BBSR with the original Anil or worse in the pouch of an Indian Airlines seat!!!

I have a strong feeling it is in BBSR because that day the orginal Anil gifted me two books (Marley & Me and a Ruskin Bond collection of stories) and in the excitement the book has been left behind.

I had very seriously wanted to write a crictical appreciation of the book and a brief synopsis too for the blog but...

Now the difficult part of honestly commenting on a book that is only half read...

I am still intrigued as to how the story will unfold. Will the couple continue to carry their past into their future or will the past dissolve as a bitter/sweet memory.... something which will not be erased totally but will not necessarily intrude with the present.

If neither then what?

Will the danger boy play the bridge? or will there be an event that will bring in a new realisation raising the couples relationship to a different level of understanding?

Does the writer desires a perfect harmonious ending or will she accept that we all live in an imperfect world and therefore a marriage too can continue without necessarily being perfect.

If after reading almost a 100 pages one can still not predict which way the plot will go then surely the writer has scored a point and deserves kudos for holding the readers interest.

Now an observation purely from a novice readers' point of view. There are places where I thought the editing could have been a bit tighter. May be, may be, the book could have been shorter by say 15 to 20 pages. This would have made the narration faster and gripped the reader better.

Nargis said...

Arun....
KYAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA? OOMG....You lost my book? It was one of a kind especially since it was gifted to one world phamous writer from another....HOW COULD YOU :-{

But hey....WOW! With this kind of critical comments I actually got over the shock of that jhatka. And to tell you the truth, don't mind gifting you another. But you better find out from Anil whether it is still here or has become food for thought for the passengers in that airline.

About the editing....actually I'm a very bad editor. Faiyaz will vouch for that. My first book went on and on for about 720 pages. It was only because of Faiyaz that I brought it down to 500 or so. Therefore compared to that this I thougth was a pretty short one..hahaha. But I love constructive criticism and I so wish you'd read it and 'criticised' it PROPAHLY! But I assure you the suspense is pretty good! Kahin kahin thoda zyaada filmi ho gaya but whoever has read it has enjoyed it..hahaha Anywayz....next time....:-}

BUT I'm still BHERRY BHERRY angry with you :-{

Vinita Deshmukh said...

Oh i just read this post and like a good editor dhapoing it for Intelligent Pune. Ok Arun? tks in advance!!!!

arun bhatt said...

Nargis ji,

how do i carry this argument forward? Maybe next time i will address you as Nigar and that might bring an end to the conversation!!! The book will definitely be traced today if it is in BBSR and then the final grand review and synopsis for the blog.

Vinita,

with great pleasure.

Faiyaz said...

Arun,

Apologies - Since I wrote about Sonam Kapoor's I got mixed up - Anil Kapoor!
Anyways say Hi to your Brother when you speak to him - Hello Brother!

Nargis said...

Okay 'Anil'Ji ;-}

Nargis said...

Okay 'Anil'Ji ;-}

arun bhatt said...

FAB

This is actually getting worse!!! You like sonam kapoor (chalo theek hai) but then when you think about me you think that I am someone of her dad's age.

Well that's one way of eliminating competition.

Hello brother has gone thru' this blog couple of days back and was mighty pleased with you.

Nargis ji,

The book has been traced. In fact it was a case of trace one get one free (William Darylymple's City of the Djins has also been found with it). And now waiting for it to reach Mumbai...

I am sure when you were addressing me as anil you were probably thinking of anil ambani!!!