Friday 19 June 2009

A BOOK REVIEW

















This novel is not so much about virginity or adultery but about relationships. And relationships not only within the socially accepted institutions like marriage, family, parental obligations but also relationships that gush out like a spring from the core of ones being- a virgin core that no adultery can pollute.

There are different forces that at times pull, at times converge and at times with the passage of time become weak and relegated to the past. How well or how badly Daya - the protagonist of this novel copes up with these forces is what this novel is all about.

Daya is in love with a mature, sensible, sensitive Sardar. Parents are naturally aghast and up in arms.

Cut to another corner of Hyderabad where there is this Hitler who responds to the name Mrs. Moorthy. She is busy doing everything that Machiavelli would have been proud of to prevent his son Rizvan marrying his lady love. Her sons’ attempted suicide too does not deter her in going ahead with her devious ways of killing this love. That Mrs. Moorthy happens to be the boss of Daya’s parents comes in handy. She bulldozes her subordinates to accept her sons’ marriage proposal.

Thus comes into being yet another Indian marriage that now falls conveniently within the norms of a conservative Hyderabadi middle-class values.

Daya and Rizwan in their own way, like most Indian middle class people of our times, try to forget their past. But the baggage of the past, despite their best efforts, always hangs like specter over them. Far from being sensitive or even understanding, Rizwan by now is bitter and short tempered person. Somehow they both put on the pretence of marriage and even have a son- Siddharth.

The theater then shifts from Hyderabad to Malaysia. Here the family tries to push back the ghosts from the past and brush out the cow-webs of the present in an attempt to recreate a paradise for the future.

It’s a brief period. A period where, to quote the author- “Sands looked whiter, the sea much bluer and the palms shade greener. They held hands and took endless walks on endless beaches. They marveled at the wonder of the bulging stretches of the blue briny waters that broke at their feet with a gentle fury.”

That’s when the storm breaks over. Daya’s ‘virginity’ like Milton’s ‘paradise” is lost. There now is a cockeyed bastard child with Malayan features in the family.

The ‘family’ returns to Hyderabad. The façade of a marriage rapidly starts crumbling. The final climax now unfolds. Daya is in the midst of a lake with her two children trying to save them and herself from drowning…..

Will they all be saved?

Will all three sink?

Will Daya be able to rescue at least one of her children?

If so who will she save? The legitimate or the ‘illegitimate’ child?

The gripping part of the novel with its ups and downs, twists and turns unfolds in the last fifty pages and that too at a thrilling speed. If you want answers to these questions and what happens next don’t read this review further but go out and buy a copy of this gripping novel.

I found the speed of the novel to be slow at the start. I would have also preferred to have the novel pruned down by at least forty five pages. 240 pages should have been the limit. This would definitely have forced the writer to go for a racy narration and led to a tighter grip on the readers.

I also wish that the author had made Rizwan’s character more rounded. There are many tender aspects to this man’s personality as seen in his attempt at a second honeymoon, or even reaching out to the ‘bastard’ child. But somehow one got the feeling that Daya was the one who was trying to bind the family and Rizwan was the one who cared a damn. A bit more empathy for Rizwan in the early stages of the marriage might have made the plot look slightly more real and maybe even more emotional.

All in all, The Virgin Adulteress is a very good novel with deep insights into the human psyche. The next time this author writes I would not hesitate to go to the nearest book stall to buy the copy.

PS: The writer of this review is NOT Nargis but Arun & the writer of the novel is NOT Arun but Nargis.
Posted by Picasa

14 comments:

Faiyaz said...

Great review Arun - Nargis is currently in Berhampur with Mummy and will only comment after her return - not before two days!

Omkar said...

So as you stepped out during the "interval" before it had graduated to "intermission", to those "inside the compound" "pan shops" (mostly in Vijaya Talkies - how dated is that), there used to be these 30 paise lyric notes in Hindi, usually of the currently playing movie. Those notes not only had the lyrics but also an introductory synopsis of the story too, that would go something like this:

E.g. Movie: Humsaya (Joy Mukherjee, Sharmila Tagore, Mala Sinha)

"Himalaya ki pahadion ke paar, Capt. ????, Chini Capt. Lin ka roop leke, Hindustan ke liye jasoosi, karte karte, Lin ki mashooka ???, ko bhi dhokhaa de rahe thay. Itnay mein idhar woh apni mangetar ko bhi kho baithnay tak aa chukay thay.

Kya Catp. ??? apni mangetar ko samjhaa sakenge, ki woh yeh Desh key liye kar rah thay. Kya woh apni mehbooba ko wapas paa sakenge?"

And it would always end (akin to Vikramaditya's Vetaal Katha) in -

"Aage parde per dekhiye".

Arun, your synopsis of Nargis Ji's novel reminded me of that ;-)

Seetha said...

After reading this review I have to get my hands on the book so I can read it!!

arun bhatt said...

FAB,

I understand the difficult times through which your family is going thru. The fact that you had to pop in and out of Hyd. also points out to the fact that things were quite serious. My efforts at reaching out to Nigar were not fruitful.My prayers are with your family.

Naresh said...

Faibhai

I seriously feel, if not shoo me away as dogmatic believer in sooth saying, consider seeing a ' Mullah' for the divine interception.

1. Your Mom's health
2. Your lurking relocation
3. Nigar's travails

You are the best judge !

Faiyaz said...

Thanks Arun and Naresh,

Even Mullahs are Mullah Minded!

Enarkay said...

Great review Arun! If the book is as good I feel like rushing to the nearest bookshop for a copy.The confusion about the author has generated good publicity on the blog

Fai
Our prayers and good wishes for your family

arun bhatt said...

hi enarkay!!
do you know what happened half an hour back. Well I was talking to vims. Do you know what he said? I quote, " I read your review of Nigar's book." Couldn't help but burst out laughing!!

Nargis said...

Hi folks...

I came back only late last night. Things are okay with mom although she is still unaware of the 'real' issue. But then I guess sometimes ignorance is bliss and we plan to keep it that way. Nigar and Nattu are coming back the day after. Shanker has gone to get them from Hyderabad...hopefully if we keep a positive approach things will be fine... Thanks guys for all the support :-}

Now for the review. Arun....Faiyaz did give me a call telling me that you'd posted a wonderful review and he especially mentioned about the clarifation of the name game reg the author/reviewer. But I just read the comments and it looks like we are back to square one. Looks like some people will never learn. Needless to say the author is still miffed with the prevailing situation. This is a DELIBERATE attempt by ONLY VIMAL to malign my bhorld phamous personality. How will my books sell if people don't even know who has written it? So I have taken the bhow that UNLESS the-still-confused-postmaster does not ask for the maafi I is NOT going to post any more of the blogs in his postcard!

Hey....I like the way you've tinkered with the name on the cover.....technology can do wonders...And after reading the review I thought...OMG, was it really me who wrote such a thrilling book ;-}
You are absolutely right about those observations (editing it to 240 and the rest)but I still stand strong with Rizvan's personality..hehehe...There are all kinds of wierdos in the world. Actually I'll send you the links of my earlier interviews. I don't think I've posted them here. And maybe later I'll try to post the blog of why I chose this title.

And Arun...thanks once again for taking the pains to read and write such a lovely review. I'm truly touched...:-}

Btw....how did you manage to find the book? Kahaan tha? And guys, I seem to be in a very benevolent mood right now so whoever's interested in the book make a trip to my house. I promise I'll hand over an autographed copy...so hurry until the stocks...oops sorry...until the mood lasts...hahahahaha!

arun bhatt said...

Hi Nargis,
Now come on it waz josht a slip of the tong on the part of Bhims. Maaf bhee kar do..

Coming back to complimentary copies, I don't think its a good idea. Our bloggers are so lazy that some might even ask you parcel it to their residential address!!

The book travelled from Bhubaneshwar, where I had left it, to Dehradun where the families met and then back to Mumbai.

Hope your next novel comes out soon.

Venu N said...

Great review, Arun---I guess I was the first guy to get confused with that picture of you and Nargis, and the book was in your hands, not hers!
BTW Nargis, I am one of those lajjy phellows Arun was talking about---you know what I'm asking?

And one more glaring mishtuk needs to be pointed out---it is 'bhaarld phamous' , not 'bhorld phamous'

Vimal Parmar said...

Maaf kar do Nigar... Oops, Nargis!
Arun: Thatz a great review.

Nargis said...

Arun: Bhy you gibhing such ideaj to our layjee phellow bloggers....see, already someone is asking phor the parcels...

Venu: Bhaarld phamous writers don't send home delibheries...so dreams dekhiba chaado and line re logi jaao...;-}

Vim: Hmmmm...tum bhi kya yaad rakhoge...chalo maaph kiya...:-}

Naresh said...

Mohatarrama Nargis

How is your book priced ? Does it command any premium ? Is it within the reach of we middle class mortals?